Skip to main content

Savings

Amex vs Discover Savings 2026: Which HYSA Wins?

Updated October 10, 2026

TL;DR

Discover Online Savings no longer accepts new applications — its page now redirects to Capital One as part of Capital One's acquisition of Discover — while American Express High Yield Savings remains open to new applicants and paid 3.10% APY as of October 10, 2026 (americanexpress.com), with no monthly fee and no minimum balance. Amex is the only one of the two still accepting new customers.

Get savings rate changes by email

Choose American Express® High Yield Savings if

Existing Amex cardholders who want banking under the same brand they trust for cards.

Choose Discover Online Savings if

Not available to new customers. Existing Discover Online Savings holders are being migrated to Capital One.

By The ClearValue Team

Head-to-head, line by line

Spec American Express® High Yield Savings Discover Online Savings
Open to new customers Yes No — discover.com sends new applicants to Capital One
APY (checked October 10, 2026) 3.10% Not offered to new customers
Monthly fee None —
Minimum to open $0 —

◈ marks the stronger option for that row. Figures checked October 10, 2026.

Update (2026): Discover is no longer accepting new savings account applications — its own savings page now redirects directly to Capital One's savings product, and Discover's deposit accounts are moving to Capital One as part of Capital One's acquisition of Discover. This page is kept for readers evaluating Amex against the field; American Express High Yield Savings remains open to new applicants.

What you would earn in a year

Interest on four balances at each rate, using the APYs each bank published when we checked on October 10, 2026.

Account APYOn $5,000On $10,000On $25,000On $50,000
American Express High Yield Savings 3.10%$155$310$775$1,550
Capital One 360 Performance Savings (where Discover's page now sends new customers) 3.10%$155$310$775$1,550
National average savings rate (FDIC, September 21, 2026) 0.37%$18.50$37$92.50$185

Assumes the balance and the APY stay the same for 12 months, with no deposits or withdrawals. Savings APYs are variable — a bank can change its rate at any time, so treat these as a snapshot, not a forecast.

Sources: americanexpress.com · capitalone.com · FDIC — National Rates and Rate Caps (monthly)

American Express® High Yield Savings

Pros

  • + Backed by American Express National Bank — strong balance sheet and brand recognition
  • + Zero fees of any kind
  • + Same Amex login as your Amex credit card accounts
  • + Customer service consistent with Amex card-side service quality

Trade-offs

  • – APY below Bask, CIT's top tier, Synchrony and Marcus (level with Ally and Capital One 360)
  • – Everyday spending needs a separate account — Amex Rewards Checking has its own eligibility terms
  • – No ATM card or cash-access functionality
  • – ACH transfers can take 1-3 business days

Discover Online Savings

Pros

  • + N/A — this account cannot be opened by new customers as of 2026.

Trade-offs

  • – Cannot be opened as a new account — Discover's own savings page redirects to Capital One.
  • – Existing Discover Online Savings accounts are being migrated to Capital One 360 Performance Savings.
  • – For a comparable no-fee, no-minimum HYSA that is currently open to new customers, see Marcus, Ally, or Capital One 360 Performance Savings on this page.

Which should you pick?

Pick American Express® High Yield Savings if: Existing Amex cardholders who want banking under the same brand they trust for cards.

Pick Discover Online Savings if: Not available to new customers. Existing Discover Online Savings holders are being migrated to Capital One.

Discover Online Savings: Not open to new applicants — Discover's savings page now serves Capital One's savings account.

What would change this verdict

  • ◆ American Express or Capital One changes its rate. The two paid the same APY when we checked, so any gap that opens becomes the tiebreaker.
  • ◆ You need cash access from savings. The Amex account has no ATM card, debit card or checks; you would pair it with a checking account elsewhere.

Keep comparing

More Savings comparisons

Related guides

Frequently asked

American Express® High Yield Savings vs Discover Online Savings — common questions

Can I still open a Discover Online Savings account to compare against Amex? +

No. As of 2026, Discover's own savings page redirects directly to Capital One's savings product page — Discover is no longer accepting new savings applications, and Discover's deposit accounts are moving to Capital One as part of Capital One's acquisition of Discover (source: capitalone.com/updates/discover/savings/). American Express High Yield Savings remains open to new applicants. See our Best High-Yield Savings Accounts 2026 roundup for currently-open accounts.

Amex or Discover for a high-yield savings account? +

For a new account there is only one answer: American Express, because Discover no longer takes new savings applications. American Express High Yield Savings paid 3.10% APY as of October 10, 2026, with no monthly fee and no minimum balance (americanexpress.com). Discover's savings page now sends applicants to Capital One 360 Performance Savings, which paid 3.10% on the same date (capitalone.com) — the same rate. So the practical comparison today is Amex versus Capital One: the Amex account is transfer-only, with no ATM card, debit card or checks, while Capital One adds branches and a checking account under one login. Both are FDIC-insured to $250,000 per depositor.

Do Amex or Discover savings charge fees or require a minimum? +

American Express High Yield Savings has no fee to open, no minimum deposit, no monthly fees and no minimum balance (americanexpress.com). Discover no longer takes new savings applications. The account its page now points to, Capital One 360 Performance Savings, has no monthly service charge and no minimum balance to open or keep the account, and its APY applies to all balances (capitalone.com).

How fast can I move money in or out? +

The American Express savings account is transfer-only: Amex says ATM cards, debit cards and checks are not provided, and that linking an external bank account can take up to two days (americanexpress.com). For everyday spending, Amex says savers may be eligible for its separate Rewards Checking account; additional terms and eligibility apply. Discover no longer opens new savings accounts. The Capital One 360 Performance Savings account that discover.com now points to lets you withdraw online or at a branch, but not at an ATM (capitalone.com). Transfer times to an outside bank vary, so check each bank's current schedule before you rely on a date.

Do I need an Amex or Discover credit card to open their savings accounts? +

Only the American Express question is still live, because Discover no longer accepts new savings applications. The American Express High Yield Savings page we read on October 10, 2026 describes opening the account with no fee and no minimum deposit and does not list an American Express Card as a requirement (americanexpress.com). Confirm current eligibility on the application before you start.

How does FDIC insurance work if I hold savings at both Amex and Discover? +

American Express National Bank is the FDIC-member bank behind Amex High Yield Savings. FDIC insurance covers deposits up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category (fdic.gov). Discover is now part of Capital One, and that changes how Discover balances are counted: Capital One states that any Capital One or Discover Bank deposit accounts opened on or after May 18, 2025 are immediately counted with your other Capital One deposit accounts when FDIC coverage is determined (capitalone.com). If you hold money at both Discover and Capital One, add the balances together and check your coverage with the FDIC's EDIE estimator at fdic.gov. Deposits at American Express National Bank are insured separately from deposits at Capital One.

Can I open a joint savings account at American Express or Discover? +

At American Express, yes. Amex describes two ownership types for its High Yield Savings Account: an Individual Account in one person's name, and a Joint Account with Right of Survivorship in the name of two persons. Amex notes that each joint account holder has equal access to the account, and that interest is reported to the IRS under the Social Security number of the primary (first-named) holder (americanexpress.com, read October 10, 2026). Discover is no longer accepting new savings applications, so a new joint Discover savings account is not an option. Under FDIC rules, joint accounts are insured up to $250,000 per co-owner at each bank (fdic.gov).

Do Amex or Discover savings offer CDs alongside the savings account? +

American Express National Bank offers CDs in multiple terms (typically 6 months to 5 years) with no minimum deposit and remains open to new applicants. Discover Bank historically offered CDs with terms from 3 months to 10 years, but Discover is no longer accepting new CD applications — its CD product has also moved to Capital One. Verify Amex's current CD terms, minimums, and penalty schedules at americanexpress.com/personalsavings.

Are there transaction limits on Amex or Discover savings withdrawals? +

Federal Regulation D historically limited certain savings-account withdrawals to six per month, but the Federal Reserve removed that mandatory cap in 2020 (federalreserve.gov). However, individual banks may still impose their own withdrawal-frequency limits and charge excessive-transaction fees beyond a published threshold. American Express publishes its own policy for the High Yield Savings Account, and Discover no longer opens new savings accounts — review the deposit account agreement before relying on unlimited withdrawals. ACH transfers count as withdrawals; in-person and ATM transactions (where applicable) are handled differently.

What credit-bureau or background check is performed when opening Amex or Discover savings? +

Both banks run a soft inquiry on ChexSystems (a deposit-account history bureau, separate from the three credit bureaus) at savings-account application — this checks for prior account closures for cause, unpaid overdrafts, or banking fraud. Neither bank performs a hard credit inquiry to open a deposit savings account, so opening does not affect your FICO score. Identity verification through Social Security number and government ID is also required to comply with Bank Secrecy Act and Customer Identification Program rules (fdic.gov). A clean ChexSystems record is the practical gating factor for online-bank account opening.

How quickly can I access funds after opening an Amex or Discover savings account? +

Discover no longer opens new savings accounts, so this applies to American Express. Amex says you can fund a new High Yield Savings Account by depositing a check with your phone, transferring from an American Express Rewards Checking account, linking your current bank, or mailing a check — and that linking an external account can take up to two days. The savings account has no ATM card, debit card or checks, so money leaves it by transfer to a linked account. Amex processes external transfers on business days (Monday through Friday, excluding federal holidays), and transfers started after 7:00 PM Eastern or on a non-business day begin processing the next business day. Source: americanexpress.com, read October 10, 2026.

Sources and method

Independent editorial comparison. ClearValue Lending is not the issuer of any product compared here.

https://clearvaluelending.com/compare/amex-vs-discover-high-yield-savings

Get savings rate updates by email