Mortgages
Cash-Out Refinance vs Home Equity Loan 2026
Free · No SSN to start
Choose Cash-Out Refinance if
Homeowners whose current mortgage rate is at or above current market rates, who want to simplify to one loan at a lower rate while accessing equity.
Choose Home Equity Loan (Second Mortgage) if
Homeowners with a low existing mortgage rate who want to access equity without giving up their first mortgage rate.
Head-to-head, line by line
| Spec | Cash-Out Refinance | Home Equity Loan (Second Mortgage) |
|---|---|---|
| Starting APR | Current 30-yr fixed rate (~6.5–7.5% May 2026) | ◈ 8–12% fixed (second lien) |
| Max amount | 80% for conventional; 85% FHA | ◈ Up to 85% CLTV |
| Max LTV | 80% for conventional; 85% FHA | Up to 85% CLTV |
| Closing costs | 2–5% of new loan amount | Lower than cash-out refi |
| Result | One loan at new rate | Two loans, first rate preserved |
◈ marks the stronger option for that row.
A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a larger one — you get the difference in cash but now have a new rate on your entire loan balance. A home equity loan adds a second mortgage while keeping your first mortgage intact. If your current rate is low, a home equity loan preserves it. If rates are lower than your current mortgage, a cash-out refi makes more sense. If you'd rather draw funds as needed instead of taking a lump sum, see how a revolving HELOC stacks up against both options.
Cash-Out Refinance
Pros
- + One loan, one payment — simplicity if consolidating first + second mortgage
- + Potentially lower rate if your current mortgage rate is above market
- + Access to full equity in one transaction — no second mortgage
- + Fixed rate available on the cash-out amount
Trade-offs
- – Replaces your entire mortgage at current rate — if your existing rate is low (2–3%), this is extremely expensive
- – Full closing costs on the entire new balance (not just the incremental cash-out)
- – If you only need a small amount of cash relative to your loan balance, closing costs rarely pencil out
Home Equity Loan (Second Mortgage)
Pros
- + Preserves your existing mortgage rate — critical if you have a 2–4% first mortgage from 2020–2022
- + Lower closing costs than cash-out refi (closing costs on second loan only)
- + Fixed rate and predictable payment on the new second mortgage
- + Right when you need a defined amount and don't want to refinance your full balance
Trade-offs
- – Two loans, two payments — added complexity
- – Higher rate than a first mortgage (second-lien risk premium)
- – Combined LTV limit may restrict how much equity you can access
- – Interest may not be tax-deductible unless used for home improvement (consult IRS Publication 936 at irs.gov)
Which should you pick?
Pick Cash-Out Refinance if: Homeowners whose current mortgage rate is at or above current market rates, who want to simplify to one loan at a lower rate while accessing equity.
Pick Home Equity Loan (Second Mortgage) if: Homeowners with a low existing mortgage rate who want to access equity without giving up their first mortgage rate.
Keep comparing
More Mortgages comparisons
Related guides
Frequently asked
Cash-Out Refinance vs Home Equity Loan (Second Mortgage) — common questions
What is the main difference between a cash-out refinance and a home equity loan? +
A cash-out refinance replaces your entire existing mortgage with a new, larger mortgage — you receive the difference in cash. A home equity loan is a separate second mortgage that sits on top of your existing mortgage without touching it. Cash-out refi makes sense when you can get a meaningfully lower rate on the new first mortgage. A home equity loan makes sense when your existing first mortgage rate is already low and you don't want to give it up. Source: CFPB guidance on home equity at consumerfinance.gov.
Which has lower closing costs — a cash-out refinance or home equity loan? +
Home equity loans generally have lower closing costs because you're taking out a smaller second loan rather than replacing the entire first mortgage. Cash-out refi closing costs (typically 2–5% of the total new loan balance) can easily exceed $8,000–$15,000 on a large mortgage. Home equity loan costs are calculated on the smaller second-loan amount — see typical HELOC costs and fees for how the revolving-line alternative compares on price. The CFPB's mortgage closing cost guidance at consumerfinance.gov has a full breakdown of typical charges.
Which is better if I have a low rate on my current mortgage? +
A home equity loan preserves your existing first mortgage and its rate. If you locked in a 3–4% rate and the current refinance rate is 6–7%, a cash-out refi would force you to replace the low-rate first mortgage. A home equity loan lets you keep that rate on the first mortgage while accessing equity through a separate second loan at current rates — typically the better structural choice when your first mortgage rate is materially below current market rates.
How much equity do I need to qualify for a home equity loan or cash-out refinance? +
Most lenders require you to retain at least 15–20% equity after the transaction — meaning you can typically borrow up to 80–85% combined loan-to-value (CLTV). For a home worth $500,000, that allows accessing up to $400,000–$425,000 in combined mortgage debt. Individual lender limits vary; some allow up to 90% CLTV for well-qualified borrowers. The credit-score bar is separate from the equity requirement — see minimum credit score for a HELOC for how lenders weigh the two together on the revolving-credit alternative. Source: CFPB at consumerfinance.gov and FDIC consumer guidance at fdic.gov.
Sources and method
- How we compare and score: ClearValue Rating methodology.
- How we write and check comparisons: editorial standards.
- Figures come from each provider's published terms. Confirm current terms with the provider before you decide.
Independent editorial comparison. ClearValue Lending is not the issuer of any product compared here.
Not sure which one fits?
Cash-Out Refinance and Home Equity Loan (Second Mortgage) are two options. One short form shows how other lenders compare for your situation.
Free · No SSN to start
https://clearvaluelending.com/compare/refinance-vs-home-equity-loan