Appraisal

An appraisal is a formal, independent opinion of an asset's value performed by a qualified appraiser — for real estate, prepared to the USPAP standard. Lenders order an appraisal to establish the collateral value that loan-to-value and advance-rate calculations are built on; the appraisal is the process, while market value, fair market value, and liquidation value are the value figures it can produce.

Real estate appraisals in the United States follow USPAP — the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, developed by the Appraisal Standards Board of The Appraisal Foundation. Federal law requires USPAP compliance for appraisals used in federally related real estate transactions, and the appraiser has no financial stake in whether the loan closes — that independence is the point of the standard. The appraiser inspects the property or asset and delivers a written report supporting a specific value conclusion. What value the appraiser is asked to conclude depends on why the lender ordered the appraisal. A conventional real estate or business loan closing typically calls for fair market value or market value — what the asset would fetch in an arm's-length sale between a willing buyer and willing seller. Asset-based lenders financing equipment or inventory often ask for a lower standard instead, such as an orderly or forced liquidation value, because that number reflects what the lender could actually recover in an expedited sale if it ever had to seize and sell the collateral. Whichever value the appraisal returns becomes the denominator lenders use to calculate loan-to-value, and for equipment or inventory financing, the basis for the advance rate the lender is willing to lend against. A full USPAP appraisal isn't the only option. A Broker Price Opinion (BPO) is a lighter-weight, less expensive value estimate prepared by a licensed real estate broker rather than a certified appraiser — lenders use it for loss mitigation, portfolio monitoring, and certain non-agency decisions where a full appraisal isn't required. Hard money lenders, who underwrite primarily on the property's loan-to-value rather than the borrower's credit, may rely on either a full appraisal or a BPO depending on loan size and lender policy.

Examples

  • A lender orders a USPAP-compliant appraisal on a commercial building before closing an SBA 504 loan; the appraised fair market value sets the ceiling on how much the lender will advance at its target loan-to-value.
  • An asset-based lender appraising a manufacturer's equipment receives two figures from the appraiser — fair market value and a lower orderly liquidation value — and sets the advance rate off the liquidation figure, not the fair market one, since that's the recoverable amount in a forced sale.
  • A lender uses a Broker Price Opinion instead of a full appraisal to check the current value of real estate collateral on an existing loan, reserving the more expensive USPAP appraisal for the original loan closing.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between an appraisal and a Broker Price Opinion (BPO)?

An appraisal is a USPAP-compliant value opinion prepared by a licensed, certified appraiser. A BPO is a less formal, less expensive estimate prepared by a real estate broker, used by lenders for loss mitigation and portfolio monitoring rather than always for a new loan's collateral valuation.

Why would a lender use liquidation value instead of fair market value for an equipment appraisal?

Asset-based lenders want the worst-case recovery number — what the equipment would bring in a forced, expedited sale — not the going-concern fair market value, since that's what the lender would actually realize if it ever had to seize and sell the collateral.

Is an appraisal always required to get a business loan?

Not always — a lender may accept a Broker Price Opinion or an internal evaluation for smaller or lower-risk transactions. But federal law requires a USPAP-compliant appraisal for federally related real estate transactions, which covers most bank and SBA real-estate-secured loan closings.

Does the appraised value determine how much a business can borrow?

Yes — the appraised value is the base figure lenders apply loan-to-value or an advance rate against. A lower appraisal directly caps the maximum loan amount at the same LTV or advance-rate ceiling; it doesn't just describe the asset, it sets the borrowing limit.

Related terms

Further reading

Part of the ClearValue family

ClearValue CardsFind your best credit cardClearValue BooksMoney & investing book picksClearValue MoneyMoney, explainedClearValue InsureFind your best coverageClearValue BankingFind your best bank account