Skip to main content
ClearValue Lending

True Cost

Lease vs buy equipment — the real cost over the life of the asset

How to decide between an operating lease, a capital ($1-buyout) lease, and an equipment loan. The 5-year cash math, Section 179 + bonus depreciation tax treatment, FASB 842 reporting, and worked scenarios for a truck, CNC machine, restaurant package, and POS system.

Four worked scenarios

  • Box truck ($60K, 7-year usage horizon). Buy. Heavy equipment with strong residual value (40–55% at year 5 for a maintained box truck), high mileage that triggers lease overage fees, qualifies for Section 179. Equipment loan or SBA 7(a) typical structure. Net cost wins by ~$8–12K over a 5-year operating lease.
  • CNC machine ($120K, 10+ year usage horizon). Buy. Long-life industrial equipment, holds value, supports a UCC-1 lien for future working-capital financing. SBA 504 often best for deals of this size — long fixed term at favorable rate.
  • Restaurant equipment package ($45K, 5–7 year horizon). Buy with a capital lease or equipment loan. Restaurant equipment depreciates faster than heavy machinery but still holds 20–30% residual. Section 179 expensing in year one materially improves cash position if the restaurant is profitable. Operating lease only makes sense if you expect to remodel or close inside 3 years.
  • POS system ($8K, 3-year tech-refresh cycle). Lease. Rapid obsolescence (payment technology, integration requirements), short horizon, often bundled with software-as-a-service and merchant processing. Operating lease + bundled support usually cheapest total cost when refresh cycle is real.

Tax treatment — Section 179, bonus, and the lease deduction

On a purchase (loan or capital lease) you elect Section 179 to expense up to the annual limit (~$2.56M in 2026, phasing out above $4.09M in total equipment purchases), then bonus depreciation under §168(k) — 100% for equipment placed in service in 2026 under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act's permanent 100% rate — on the remainder, then MACRS depreciation on what's left over the asset's class life. The combination usually lets a profitable business deduct the entire cost in year one for equipment under the §179 limit.

On an operating lease, you deduct lease payments as operating expense in the year paid. For long-horizon assets, the §179 + bonus depreciation election on a purchase typically delivers larger total tax benefit than the year-by-year lease deduction — but the timing matters: a business with low current-year taxable income may not be able to use a large §179 deduction immediately.

FASB Topic 842 — what changed (and what didn't)

Effective for private companies in 2022, FASB ASC Topic 842 requires almost all leases over 12 months to be capitalized on the balance sheet as a right-of-use asset and a lease liability. The income-statement treatment depends on whether the lease is classified as operating or finance. Tax treatment is unchanged — the IRS still applies the true-lease vs conditional-sale test from Rev. Rul. 55-540 and subsequent guidance. Book and tax can diverge.

Hidden costs of leasing

  • End-of-lease documentation and disposition fees — often $300–$1,500 per asset.
  • Restoration to original condition — meaningful on commercial vehicles and restaurant equipment.
  • Mileage and usage overage — vehicles $0.15–$0.25 per excess mile; certain machinery hour-based overage charges.
  • Fair-market-value buyout balloon — on FMV-buyout leases, the buyout can land 5–30% of original cost. Get the buyout mechanic in writing.
  • Early termination fees — leases are expensive to exit before term.

Takeaways

  • Operating lease wins on short-horizon, rapid-obsolescence assets with low residual value (POS, certain tech).
  • Capital lease / equipment loan wins on long-horizon assets with meaningful residual (vehicles, industrial machinery, restaurant equipment).
  • Section 179 + bonus depreciation make first-year purchase economics much more attractive than they look on cash flow alone.
  • FASB 842 capitalized lease accounting did not change the tax treatment of leases.
  • Compare quotes apples-to-apples by demanding total cost in writing — monthly × term + every defined end-of-lease charge.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between an operating lease and a capital lease?

An operating lease is a true rental — you pay to use the equipment for a defined term and return it (or buy out at fair-market-value residual). Lease payments are deducted as operating expense. A capital lease (a.k.a. $1-buyout lease, a.k.a. finance lease) is structured so you own the equipment at end of term for a nominal payment. It's economically equivalent to a loan and is treated for tax purposes as a purchase — eligible for Section 179 expensing and bonus depreciation. Under FASB ASC Topic 842 (effective for private companies in 2022), almost all leases over 12 months must be capitalized on the balance sheet — but the tax treatment still distinguishes between the two structures.

What's the Section 179 limit and bonus depreciation rate in 2026?

Section 179 allows immediate expensing of qualifying equipment up to $2,560,000 in 2026, phasing out dollar-for-dollar once total equipment purchases exceed $4,090,000 (IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32 §4.24, indexed from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act's base). Bonus depreciation under IRC §168(k) is 100% for equipment placed in service in 2026 — the OBBBA made 100% bonus depreciation permanent for qualifying property placed in service after January 19, 2025, ending the prior phase-down schedule toward 0% that older guidance still describes. Financing the purchase doesn't reduce either benefit — both are based on the full cost of the asset, not how much cash you put down.

Is equipment-financing demand actually picking up in 2026?

Yes, sharply. The Equipment Leasing and Finance Association tracked $14.3 billion equipment deals in July 2026 alone across its member survey — a new monthly record, 24.5% above the prior all-time high, with the surge driven largely by AI-related capital investment. ELFA's full-year 2026 forecast is $137.3 billion new deals across the industry, which would beat 2024's previous record by 14.0%. That's the demand backdrop behind the lease-vs-buy decision on this page: more businesses are financing equipment right now than at any point in the index's two-decade history, which is exactly when getting the lease-vs-buy math right (not just the monthly payment) matters most.

Does FASB Topic 842 change the tax treatment of a lease?

No. FASB 842 is a financial-reporting (GAAP) standard — it changed how leases appear on the balance sheet, not the tax treatment. For tax, the IRS still distinguishes between true leases and conditional sales (capital leases). An operating lease for GAAP can still be a true lease for tax; a capital lease for GAAP can still be a financed purchase for tax. The categorization differs, so book and tax can diverge — your CPA or tax advisor reconciles.

When does lease win over buy on the math?

Operating lease wins when: (1) usage horizon is short — you'll outgrow or obsolete the equipment in 24–36 months; (2) technology turnover is rapid — POS systems, certain medical imaging, certain compute hardware; (3) cash conservation matters more than ownership — startup phase, growth phase; (4) maintenance is bundled with the lease (some operating leases include service); (5) the residual value is genuinely uncertain and you don't want to bear it. Otherwise, buying (loan or capital lease) usually wins on total cost.

When does buying win clearly?

Buy wins when: (1) usage horizon is long — 7+ years of expected use; (2) residual value is meaningful — heavy equipment, commercial vehicles, certain industrial machines; (3) you'll use the equipment as collateral for future financing — owned equipment supports a UCC-1 lien; (4) Section 179 and bonus depreciation give you a large first-year deduction that materially helps current-year taxes. The total cash-out math almost always favors buying on long-horizon assets.

What are the hidden costs of leasing?

End-of-lease fees: documentation fees, dispositional fees, restoration-to-original-condition costs (a real number on commercial vehicles and restaurant equipment). Mileage and usage caps on vehicles and certain machines — overage charges can be material. Maintenance obligations specified in the lease vs the operating-cost reality. Early termination fees: leases are hard to exit before term. Residual / buyout balloon: a 'fair-market-value' buyout can land anywhere from 5% to 30% of original cost. Compare apples-to-apples by demanding the total lease cost in writing — monthly × term + all defined end-of-lease charges.

Can I get an SBA loan for equipment?

Yes. SBA 7(a) is commonly used for equipment purchases up to $5M with terms up to 10 years for working capital and equipment (25 years if real estate is included). SBA 504 is purpose-built for fixed assets including equipment — typically structured as 50% bank / 40% CDC (SBA) / 10% borrower equity at favorable long-term fixed rates. Both require personal guarantees from 20%+ owners. SBA 504 is often the lowest all-in cost for equipment purchases in the $500K+ range; SBA 7(a) is faster for smaller deals and better for mixed-purpose financing (equipment + working capital).

What's a sale-leaseback and when does it make sense?

A sale-leaseback is a transaction where you sell owned equipment to a financing company and immediately lease it back. Use cases: extracting trapped equity from owned equipment to fund growth or refinance higher-cost debt, or moving an asset off the balance sheet (less relevant post-FASB 842). The downside: you lose ownership, lease payments add up to more than the cash received, and you may owe tax on any gain if the equipment was depreciated below sale price (depreciation recapture). Sale-leaseback often makes sense as a one-time strategic move; rarely a default financing choice.

Are there tax credits for equipment purchases?

Some sector-specific federal credits exist: §45L (energy-efficient buildings), §48 (solar / energy property), Investment Tax Credit (ITC) for renewable energy, and various state-level economic development credits. The Inflation Reduction Act expanded several energy-related credits — some apply to equipment used in qualifying business activities. These are highly fact-specific; coordinate with a CPA before assuming a credit applies. The general business credit (Form 3800) consolidates many sector-specific credits; carryback/carryforward rules apply.

Should I lease or buy a vehicle through my business?

Depends on annual mileage and ownership horizon. High-mileage operators (over 25K/yr): buy — lease mileage caps make leasing punitive. Low-mileage owners with frequent vehicle refreshes (sales reps, executive use): lease can win on simplicity. For trade vehicles (box truck, work van, service vehicle) where you'll keep the vehicle 6–10 years: buy almost always wins on total cost. Section 179 and bonus depreciation favor purchases of qualifying heavy SUVs and trucks (over 6,000 lbs GVWR) in the first year.

Start an application

More on the true cost of borrowing

Published 2026-06-20 · Updated 2026-08-25 · https://clearvaluelending.com/answers/true-cost/lease-vs-buy-equipment

Find my match

Free · Takes ~60 sec · No spam