Highest claims-approval rate in independent surveys with strong contractor quality.
Get started at Liberty Home Guard → Pre-qualify (where available) with a soft credit pull — no score impact.
ClearValue Rating: 4.2 / 5 — our editorial assessment (how we rate)
Editorial confidence (30%), cost (25%), value (25%), accessibility (20%) — scored consistently across every product, independent of compensation.
Homeowners willing to pay slightly more for higher actual-payout reliability.
Liberty Home Guard — Highest claims-approval rate in independent surveys with strong contractor quality. Best for: Homeowners willing to pay slightly more for higher actual-payout reliability.. Compare it against alternatives before applying; the right fit depends on your situation, credit, and goals.
The workmanship guarantee means that if a covered repair fails within 60 days of completion, Liberty Home Guard will send a technician back to fix the same issue without charging an additional service-call fee. This reduces the risk of paying multiple service fees for the same problem — a common frustration with home warranty claims. Verify the specific terms of the guarantee in your contract, including what qualifies as the 'same issue' and any exclusions.
Liberty Home Guard offers multiple service-call fee tiers ($65, $85, $125). A lower service-call fee typically comes with a higher monthly premium, while a higher service-call fee reduces the monthly cost. Which tier makes sense depends on how often you expect to file claims. Homeowners with older systems who expect frequent service calls may benefit from the lower-fee tier; homeowners with newer systems might prefer a lower monthly premium and accept the higher per-claim cost. Compare the break-even math before choosing.
Liberty Home Guard offers more than 38 specific add-on items — covering things like stand-alone freezers, pool equipment, well pumps, and other systems not included in standard plans. These add-ons matter when you have specific systems that standard plans exclude. Review the base plan's covered-items list carefully against your home's actual systems before deciding which add-ons are necessary. The FTC's service contract guidance at consumer.ftc.gov is useful background for evaluating contract terms.
No. ClearValue Lending is not a licensed insurance broker or service-contract agent. This review presents editorial information. Home warranty contracts are service contracts, not insurance policies, and are regulated differently by state. Read the full contract — including covered items, exclusion list, and per-item caps — before purchasing.
How we rate
Every pick gets a 1–5 ClearValue Rating computed from four weighted factors: Editorial confidence (30%), Cost (25%), Value (25%), and Accessibility (20%).
Scored consistently across every product and independent of any compensation. Full methodology →
Advertiser disclosure: some links are from our partners — we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Rankings and editorial assessments are independent of compensation.